Fitness watches comparison · Maker specs

Apple Watch Ultra 4 vs Garmin fēnix 8

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See Affiliate disclosure. This guide summarizes the makers’ published specs below — we haven’t tested them ourselves. See Methodology.

Quick Answer

Buy Apple Watch Ultra 4 if you use an iPhone and want satellite messaging, cellular, a 3,000-nit screen and Apple's new heart sensors, from $799. Buy the 47mm Garmin fēnix 8 if you use Android or want battery measured in days: up to 16 days as a smartwatch, or 7 with the screen always on, from $999.99 at its 2024 launch. Ultra 4 is rated for 50 hours of normal use.

The verdict

Get Apple Watch Ultra 4 if you're on iPhone and want a watch that can reach help on its own, over cellular or satellite; get Garmin fēnix 8 if you want to stay free to use any phone and charge only every week or two.

Why: Both carry maps, a flashlight and EN 13319 certification for 40-meter dives. Ultra 4 can reach emergency services and send messages by satellite and connects over 5G RedCap and LTE; the fēnix 8 has neither radio, so calls go through your phone. With GPS on, the battery gap narrows: Ultra 4 is rated for up to 45 hours in Max Extended Workout, the fēnix 8 for up to 47 hours GPS-only.

Buy Apple Watch Ultra 4 if

You use an iPhone, you want to reach help by satellite or call over cellular when your phone isn't with you, and you'll use the daily readiness score.

Buy Garmin fēnix 8 if

You use Android or change phones often, you'd rather charge every week or two, or you want a proper LED flashlight with a red light for nights outside.

Garmin announced the fēnix 8 on 27 August 2024, two years before Apple’s Ultra 4 arrived on 9 September 2026, and Garmin has since moved on to the fēnix 9. The fēnix 8 also comes in 43mm and 51mm AMOLED sizes and in Solar versions, each with different battery life; the ratings below are for the 47mm AMOLED.

Key specs

SpecApple Watch Ultra 4Garmin fēnix 8 (47mm AMOLED)
Announced9 September 202627 August 2024
Works withiPhone 11 or later, iOS 27iPhone or Android (Garmin Connect)
SoftwarewatchOS 27Garmin’s own
Case49 × 44 × 12mm Grade 5 titanium47mm; thickness not published
Weight63.0 g natural; 63.1 g blackNot published
DisplayAlways-On LTPO3 OLED, 422 × 514, up to 3,000 nitsAMOLED; resolution and brightness not published
Everyday batteryUp to 50 hours; 84 in Low Power ModeUp to 16 days with gesture; 7 always-on; 23 battery saver
GPS battery18 hours; 25 Extended; 45 Max Extended Workout47 hours GPS-only; 35 multi-band; 81 Max Battery GPS
SatelliteSOS, Messages, Find MyNone; no inReach
Cellular5G RedCap and LTENone
Water and diving100m; EN 13319 to 40m10 ATM; EN 13319 to 40m
FlashlightScreen flashlight on the Action ButtonLED with red light and strobe
US launch price$799Series from $999.99

The phone you use comes first

Ultra 4 needs an iPhone 11 or later, including iPhone SE (2nd generation or later), on iOS 27, and there’s no Android setup. Its cellular, satellite and safety features work within Apple’s rules for the paired iPhone, and you get watchOS 27, Apple Pay and GymKit. If your days already run on Apple Pay, iMessage and a cellular plan on your wrist, it fits straight in, but it won’t follow you to Android.

The fēnix 8 pairs with an iPhone or an Android phone through Garmin Connect, which carries notifications, music services, Garmin Messenger and LiveTrack. It runs Garmin’s own software, not Wear OS or watchOS, and Garmin Pay works in the countries and with the banks Garmin supports. If you change phones every few years, it’s the one that won’t make you change watch brands too.

Battery: hours against days

ModeApple Watch Ultra 4Garmin fēnix 8 (47mm AMOLED)
EverydayUp to 50 hours normal useUp to 16 days smartwatch with gesture; 7 days always-on
Low powerUp to 84 hours Low Power ModeUp to 23 days battery saver
GPSUp to 18 hours outdoor workout; 25 hours Extended WorkoutUp to 47 hours GPS-only; 38 all systems; 35 multi-band
GPS, screen always onNo separate ratingUp to 37, 30 and 28 hours
Longest GPS modeUp to 45 hours Max Extended WorkoutUp to 81 hours Max Battery GPS
Multi-day modeNone listedUp to 17 days Expedition
GPS with musicNo rating givenUp to 10 hours
Quick charge15 minutes for up to 18 hours of normal useNo rating given

The headline numbers measure different things. Fifty hours is Apple’s normal-use day; 16 days is Garmin’s smartwatch mode with the screen waking when you raise your wrist, not 16 days of GPS. With GPS running, the gap is much smaller than it looks: up to 45 hours on Ultra 4 in Max Extended Workout against 47 hours GPS-only on the fēnix 8, which stretches to 81 in Max Battery GPS mode. Apple’s 45 hours covers outdoor running, walking and hiking with GPS checking your position every second; it doesn’t apply to swimming, cycling or diving.

Ultra 4 comes with a Magnetic Fast Charger to USB-C and reaches about 80 percent in 45 minutes, and 5 minutes on it buys up to 10 hours of sleep tracking. Charge the fēnix 8 between 0 and 45 degrees Celsius, Garmin says.

Satellite, cellular and safety

Ultra 4 sends Emergency SOS, Messages and Find My over satellite, and it’s a cellular watch with 5G RedCap and LTE, so it can reach people when your phone isn’t with you. Hold the Action Button and it sounds a siren Apple says carries about 180 meters; the same button can start a workout or the screen flashlight.

The 47mm fēnix 8 has neither radio: no inReach and no cellular. It takes calls through its speaker and microphone while paired, and some voice commands work without the phone nearby, but incident detection, assistance and LiveTrack all need the phone. Garmin Messenger sends two-way texts when both people have the app. What it adds is a dedicated LED flashlight with variable intensity, a red light and a strobe, a different thing from Apple’s screen flashlight.

If you want to text from beyond cell range without a phone, only Ultra 4 does it.

Screen and case

Ultra 4’s Always-On LTPO3 OLED sits under flat sapphire: 422 by 514 pixels at 326 pixels per inch, up to 3,000 nits and down to 1 nit. The Grade 5 titanium case is 49 millimeters tall, 44 wide and 12 thick, weighs 63.0 grams in natural titanium or 63.1 grams in black without a band, and fits wrists from 130 to 210 millimeters. One band comes in the box; this year’s sport bands are the Trail Loop, Alpine Loop and a translucent Ocean Band.

Garmin calls the fēnix 8’s display a bright AMOLED and makes the sapphire lens optional, but it doesn’t give the 47mm model’s brightness, resolution, weight, thickness, processor or storage.

Maps, training and health

Ultra 4 has offline maps, U.S. topographic maps and curated hikes in all 63 U.S. national parks, and its running metrics include power. Apple’s Health Sensing System checks your heart rate in the background every five seconds and feeds a daily readiness score from 0 to 10. Sleep tracking covers stages and a Sleep score, with sleep apnea notifications where Apple offers them, and ECG and Blood Oxygen depend on your region.

On the fēnix 8, TopoActive maps come on sapphire models, other versions download maps, and Outdoor Maps+ is a subscription. Garmin offers an ECG app in some regions, for ages 22 and up, and a wrist-based Pulse Ox reading that isn’t a medical device and isn’t available in every country. Sleep tracking adds nap detection, a morning report and Body Battery, but Garmin lists no skin-temperature sensor.

Diving and durability

Both carry EN 13319 certification for dives to 40 meters, with different tools underwater. Ultra 4’s depth gauge is accurate to about 1 meter, dive apps open automatically at 1 meter, and it has a water-temperature sensor. The fēnix 8 reads depth from 0 to 40 meters at 0.1-meter resolution, works underwater from 0 to 40 degrees Celsius, has scuba and apnea modes, and is the one that names a decompression model, Bühlmann ZHL-16C.

Ultra 4 adds IP6X dust protection and a list of specific MIL-STD-810H tests, and Apple rates it for minus 20 to 55 degrees Celsius on the wrist and altitudes from minus 500 to 9,000 meters.

Price

Ultra 4 starts at $799 in the US; bands, the Hermès edition, a cellular plan and AppleCare cost extra. Garmin’s suggested price for the fēnix 8 range started at $999.99 on 27 August 2024, and sapphire, a titanium bezel and the larger sizes change it, while the Solar models have different batteries altogether. Garmin’s higher launch price pays for days of battery, maps and the freedom to switch phones; Apple’s lower one pays for satellite messaging, cellular and a 3,000-nit screen, as long as you stay on iPhone. Prices move, so check apple.com and garmin.com before you buy.

Frequently asked questions

Does Garmin fēnix 8 work with an iPhone?

Yes. It pairs with an iPhone or an Android phone through Garmin Connect for notifications, music services, Garmin Messenger and LiveTrack. Ultra 4 is iPhone-only: it needs an iPhone 11 or later, including iPhone SE (2nd generation or later), on iOS 27.

Which one lasts longer between charges?

The fēnix 8, by days. Garmin rates the 47mm AMOLED for up to 16 days as a smartwatch with gesture backlight, 7 days with the screen always on and 23 days in battery saver. Ultra 4 is rated for 50 hours of normal use, or 84 in Low Power Mode. The two companies test differently, but the everyday gap is real.

Does this fēnix 8 have inReach or cellular?

No. The 47mm AMOLED fēnix 8 has neither; calls use its speaker and microphone while it's paired to your phone, and the LTE features belong to fēnix 8 Pro. Ultra 4 is cellular, with 5G RedCap and LTE, and adds satellite SOS, Messages and Find My.

Can both dive to 40 meters?

Yes. Both meet EN 13319 for 40-meter dives, but the ratings around that differ. Ultra 4 is water resistant to 100 meters and its depth gauge works to 40 meters; the fēnix 8 is rated 10 ATM with a separate 4 ATM dive rating, and its depth sensor reads from 0 to 40 meters.

Sources